Politics

After the Russell Brand case, how might a staggered age of consent work?

After the Russell Brand case, how might a staggered age of consent work?

Russell Brand’s crimes – and similar high-profile cases – have raised the question of whether sexual relationships between people of widely differing ages – often with a severe power imbalance – should be regulated in Britain.

In a number of other jurisdictions, a maximum legal age gap is set; in some cases, it varies with the age of the younger person. Mia Latter, who accuses Brand of having groomed and taken advantage of her when she was 16 and he was 30, is leading calls for a change in the law. “If you’re in your thirties, forties, and fifties and you’re trying to have a relationship with someone under the age of 18, it [should] be a criminal offence,” she says. Brand, 51, who was this month jailed for 10 years and six months for rape and three sexual assaults during the height of his fame, asserted that they had a consensual relationship. Ministers are actively considering the options.

Currently, the sexual age of consent is set at 16 across the UK; it is suggested that this could be modified to 17 or 18 to restrict sexual activity with someone more than, for example, five years older (but, under what’s termed a “Romeo and Juliet” clause, only the older party would be criminalised). It is also suggested that the punishment for a rape or other assault might be made more severe than would apply between two adults of similar age.

There would need to be legal definitions of what constitutes sexual activity and how any new laws would interact with laws against grooming. It has been illegal for some years for anyone aged 18 or over to intentionally send sexual communication or elicit a sexual response from a child under 16; this covers online and offline interactions. So-called sexting is also against the law, even if the younger person consents. What constitutes sexual activity – not just sexual intercourse – would require some clarification.

Any sex with or between somebody of 15, 14 or 13 is deemed unlawful “sexual activity with a child”, and with someone under the age of 12 it is rape. There are some other restrictions, centred on abuse of positions of trust; for example, teachers or employers cannot have sex with someone aged 16.

In Italy, the legal age of consent is 14 but a 13-year-old can also engage in sexual activity with someone as long as there is no more than three years’ age difference between them. By contrast, the general age of consent in Florida is 18 but the close-in-age exemption means someone of 16 or 17 can legally consent to sexual activity with a partner who is 23 or under.

One potential issue is whether restrictions should also apply to someone who is old enough – 18 or even, say, 21 – but might be too emotionally vulnerable for the attention of someone much older than them. Put more directly, an offender might simply wait until their victim’s 18th or 21st birthday, rather than their 16th at present. Indeed, a broader definition of abusing a position of authority, with no arbitrary age limits, might be a more useful deterrent across all age ranges.

Nothing immediately because it will take time to make the necessary consultations and change the law. But there does seem to be some momentum behind the idea, after decades of shocking stories, and the fact that many other advanced nations have implemented such legislation adds to the pressure for change.

Gavin Stephens, the chair of the National Police Chiefs’ Council, says police would need to “look carefully” at how any changes would work, but added: “If there is a better way to avoid, in particular, powerful men in positions of influence being able to exploit vulnerable people and to strengthen the legislation, then we should consider it.”

He says policing chiefs should “actively” join the debate over consent laws in the wake of Brand’s trial, adding: “We should have a voice in what comes next from our professional experience, and we would need to look carefully about how that works.”

You may have missed